Cleansing Balms vs. Makeup Wipes: Which Is Right for You?

When you remove your makeup at night, do you use makeup removing wipes or a cleansing balm? Both of these methods are designed to help remove traces of makeup, dirt and pollution from the skin, but one may be better than the other, depending on your complexion and preference. According to Skincare.com experts Dr. Hadley King, a NYC-based board-certified dermatologist and Nicole Hatfield, an esthetician at Pomp, your skin type is a determining factor when choosing between makeup remover wipes and cleansing balms. Ahead, our experts break down the similarities and differences of wipes and balms and explain which may work better for you. 

Cleansing Balms vs. Makeup Wipes

The Similarities and Differences

Both Dr. King and Hatfield agree that both balms and makeup wipes are effective ways to remove face makeup, but there are a few notable differences between the two methods. “Cleansing balms tend to be more gentle on the skin because they are usually oil-based and work by dissolving makeup on the face and then rinsed away” says Hatfield. They are a better choice for thoroughly cleansing the face if you wear a lot of makeup. Alternatively, makeup wipes can be enough to cleanse the skin if you wear light to medium makeup only, says Dr. King (shout out to our favorite Garnier SkinActive Micellar Makeup Remover Wipes). 

Who Can Benefit From Using Cleansing Balms?

On the other hand, all skin types can benefit from using cleansing balms. They are well-suited for dry and sensitive skin types because “they won’t strip the skin of its natural oils and cause drying,” says Dr. King. “But if you have very oily and acne-prone skin and you are not sufficiently removing excess oils, dead skin cells, bacteria and potentially comedogenic material, then a more thorough cleansing method could help avoid to clogged pores and acne breakouts.”

She recommends a double-cleansing method, in which you begin by cleansing your face with an oil-based cleansing balm, like the Glow Recipe Papaya Enzyme Sorbet Cleansing Balm, and follow up with a water-based cleanser, like the CeraVe Cream to Foam Cleanser.

 Design: Hannah Packer

 

Read More:

The Best Cleanses for Oily Skin, Hands Down

Is SPF Additive?

What Causes Ashen Skin? — Plus, How to Get Rid of It